WE ARE OPEN M-F 11-4 & S 10-2 FOR RETAIL SALES. YOU CAN ALSO ORDER ON LINE OR BY PHONE. DELIVERY AVAILABLE.
YOU HAVE DISCOVERED THE HOME OF THE AWARD WINNING KEY LIME PIE. THE CARIBBEAN PIE COMPANY IS THE PLACE TO PURCHASE KEY LIME PIE (IN ADDITION TO OTHER DELICIOUS VARIETIES). WE ALSO HAVE CHEESECAKES, BUNDT CAKES, FUDGE, GLAZED NUTS, AND OF COURSE THE FAMOUS KEY LIME PIE ON A STICK! A FAMOUS KEY WEST INVENTION!!
We will be taking orders for our holiday pies beginning November 1. In addition to our Pecan, Pumpkin, and Apple Crumbs pies, we will also have Pumpkin bundt and Pumpkin cheesecake available to order. All orders must be placed by Wednesday, November 17.
CAKES ARE AVAILBLE IN OUR SIGNATURE KEY LIME FLAVOR, AS WELL AS COCONUT, ORANGE, LEMON, AND RUM. CHOOSE FROM BUNDLETS, BUNDTINIS OR BUNDT CAKE. ALL CAKES HAVE A LIGHT GLAZE (NO HEAVY ICING) TO ENHANCE THE FLAVOR.
OUR CHEESECAKES ARE MADE WITH THE HIGHEST QUALITY INGREDIENTS. WE USE CHEESE AND EGGS, NO FLOUR OR ADDED FILLERS. EACH CAKE IS INDIVIDUALLY MADE TO ORDER. THESE ARE THE "NEW YORK" VARIETY, DENSE AND RICH. CHEESECAKES MUST BE ORDERED 3 DAYS IN ADVANCE. OTHER SIZES AVAILABLE.
The Caribbean Pie Company offers small almond cakes, mini cream puffs, key lime bites, shortbread tarts, mini cheesecakes and phyllo tarts. These are perfect for your next event! Call for more information.
PLEASE ORDER 3 DAYS IN ADVANCE.
AVAILABLE FOR YOUR NEXT EVENT. A LARGE GREEN AND WHITE UMBRELLA IS ATTACHED TO THIS ROLLING, LIGHTWEIGHT CART. FREEZER INSERTS KEEP THINGS COLD FOR HOURS. NO ELECTRICITY REQUIRED. CALL FOR MORE INFORMATION.
GIFT CERTIFICATES AVAILABLE
Instead of an ordinary gift surprise the recipient with a pie or gift certificate for a pie of their choice! A delicious gift that will be savored by all. Delivery of a boxed pie including a card with your personal message available in addition to gift certificates.
We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.
2245 Bee Ridge Road, Sarasota, Florida 34239, United States
10:00 am – 02:00 pm